Build a small test set
Product detail: “Create a clean studio photo of an amber glass perfume bottle on pale limestone. Keep the bottle silhouette and cap shape exact; use soft window light and a short shadow.” Check whether the glass, cap and label stay distinct.
Lettering: “Design a simple cream poster with the exact headline ‘SUNDAY MARKET’ and the smaller line ‘FRESH FLOWERS · 9 AM’. Use a dark green serif headline and leave open space around the type.” Compare every character and its placement.
Edges: “Place the person from the source photo in a bright room with a warm gray wall. Keep the face, hair outline and jacket unchanged; do not add objects.” Inspect hair, shoulders and other fine boundaries against the original.
Keep each run easy to review
Use the same source image, prompt and output settings where both services allow it. Save original files and record the model, provider, date, price and number of retries.
Review shape accuracy, text, texture and edges as separate questions. Keep failed runs beside successful ones; a single favorite image does not describe a repeatable workflow.
Use the same inputs and save original files when you repeat these tests.